Bills to Avoid on Autopay: Save Money and Stay in Control

Share with your friends!

Facebook Pinterest Messenger WhatsApp Email Flipboard Reddit SMS X

A person sits on a couch, looking serious, holding a calculator to their ear, with a laptop and papers on a table in front of them. — Image Credit: DepositPhotos

Autopay can seem like the perfect financial safety net, helping you avoid missed payments and costly late fees. Although, setting every bill on autopay isn’t always the best option. The convenience of autopay can come with a few pitfalls that often go unnoticed, sometimes, these issues can lead to unnecessary expenses or a strained budget.

For example, did you know that subscription services alone can rack up extra charges when their rates increase without notice? According to a recent study, Americans spend an average of $133 more per month on subscriptions they no longer use simply because these charges fly under the radar.

This guide covers which bills might be better managed manually and highlights the reasons behind it. We’ll discuss how autopay could affect your financial awareness and provide actionable advice on when paying bills yourself is a smarter move.

Are there any bills you’ve been unsure about putting on autopay? Tell us in the comments, or read to the end to see if any of these surprise you!

Credit Card Bills

A woman in a white shirt sits on a couch with plants in the background, holding a credit card and looking at a laptop.

In 2022, Americans paid over $12 billion in credit card late fees due to missed payments. Putting credit card payments on autopay sounds convenient, but it can create issues if balances fluctuate.

Also, fraudulent or incorrect charges can slip through unnoticed with autopay. A manual review gives you the chance to dispute unfamiliar charges, which keeps your balance accurate. Ensuring accuracy avoids unnecessary financial strain and keeps your budget on track.

20 Credit Card Mistakes Many People Make (And How to Fix Them)

Utility Bills

A woman looks tired while sitting at a desk with a laptop, a document in one hand, and a calculator nearby.

Inaccurate utility billing data can lead to additional costs for customers ranging from 5% to 15% annually. Autopay can overlook these variations, which may catch you off guard with unexpectedly high deductions during peak usage times.

Some utility companies may apply incorrect charges, double billing, or extra fees that go unnoticed on autopay. Paying personally provides a chance to spot and address these issues before they impact your budget, saving both time and frustration down the line.

15 Easy Ways To Lower Your Electricity Bill

Earn Free Gift Cards

Swagbucks: Coupons, Paid Online Surveys & Free Gift Cards

Do you want to make money online simply by searching, shopping, surveys, or playing games?

Pros:

Account creation is free
Big bonus on sign up
Many ways to earn free money
Mobile-friendly rewards site and apps
Simple to complete tasks
$10 to sign up

Cons:

Not exactly passive income
Redeeming SB points sometimes takes awhile
It isn't easy to qualify for all surveys
Customer service isn't the greatest (or fastest)

Earn Free Money Now

ChaChingQueen Review

Gym Memberships

A group of people is exercising in a gym, focusing on a woman in the foreground lifting dumbbells. With others lifting weights behind her, the scene reflects the fitness lifestyle often embraced by those with an upper middle class income.

Gym memberships may have complex cancellation policies that cause unintended charges. During times when you aren’t using the gym, this recurring charge can become an unnecessary expense.

Autopay also complicates negotiations. Many gyms offer discounts or waive fees to retain members, but automatic deductions reduce your leverage. By paying manually, you have a better opportunity to negotiate and make sure your payment reflects only what you agreed upon.

How To Save Money And Take Care Of Your Health

Car Insurance

A man and a woman are sitting in a car, with the man driving and the woman in the passenger seat. Both are smiling. They are dressed in casual white shirts.

Car insurance premiums may increase unexpectedly on autopay. Premiums may increase due to policy adjustments, regional changes, or claim impacts, and autopay could result in a higher deduction than expected.

When you handle this payment actively, you’re reminded to check for better offers that can save money on coverage. Also, manually paying your car insurance bill gives you control over policy modifications.

How To Save On Car Insurance: 13 Ways To Lower Car Insurance Premiums

Property Taxes

A person is sitting with a laptop on their lap, holding documents and a calculator, possibly working on finances or taxes.

Property tax payments are significant and often variable. Putting them on autopay can lead to surprise deductions, especially if local tax rates increase unexpectedly. Another risk is overpaying property taxes due to miscalculations or changes in tax assessments.

Handling property taxes personally can also allow for more strategic payment timing. Depending on local policies, some homeowners benefit from paying taxes at certain times of the year.

Autopay lacks this flexibility, but manual payments allow for choices that may better suit your financial goals.

12 Upgrades That Skyrocket Your Property Value (And 12 Mistakes That Tank It

Medical Bills

A healthcare provider measures the blood pressure of an older adult woman using a sphygmomanometer in a clinical setting, reminding her to stop doing these if 75: strenuous exercises and unapproved medications.

A recent report found that up to 80% of medical bills contain errors. Automatic deductions can withdraw more than expected, especially with ongoing treatments or changes in coverage. Billing errors in medical charges are common, and autopay makes it easy to miss these mistakes.

By reviewing each medical bill individually, you gain a chance to correct any errors before paying. This avoids unnecessary spending on incorrect charges and helps you stay within your medical budget.

How To Lower the Costs Of Your Healthcare Bills

Cell Phone Bills

Elderly woman with glasses and red hair sits on a couch, using a smartphone.

While cell phone bills are usually consistent, autopay on these accounts can lead to missed savings. Many providers offer incentives for bundling or discounts that may require a direct approach.

Also, certain providers add charges for extra data or services. By reviewing each bill, you’ll know when your data use or additional service costs exceed expectations. Direct payments let you monitor usage and avoid unexpected charges, keeping your phone bill predictable.

How I Made A Few Phone Calls And Lowered My Monthly Bills

Internet Bills

A woman sitting on a sofa uses a laptop, with a pink wall and green pillows in the background.

Autopaying internet bills can mask promotional rates that eventually expire, leading to unexpected price hikes. Internet providers often introduce rate increases after the first year, and autopay makes it easy to miss these changes.

Some internet providers offer loyalty discounts or special rates that may be easier to negotiate without autopay. Handling internet bills manually allows you to ask for better rates or renegotiate terms, preventing bill inflation and ensuring value for your money.

Don’t Miss These 30 Decent Discounts That Seniors Forget to Claim

Mortgage Payments

Mortgage payments are large, and autopay can make you overlook the impact on your cash flow. Proactively managing mortgage payments lets you assess your finances monthly, ensuring the payment won’t cause an overdraft.

Mortgage companies sometimes make errors, like applying payments incorrectly or adding fees. Personally handling payments allows for regular review, ensuring accuracy and preventing complications.

19 Ways to Slash Your Monthly Mortgage Payments (Some Are Smart)

Water Bills

Close-up of water flowing from a chrome faucet with steam rising, suggesting hot water.

Water bills vary with usage and can increase unexpectedly due to leaks or high use. Autopay may deduct large amounts without warning, putting strain on your budget. Paying water bills manually lets you track usage, avoiding sudden deductions.

Water providers sometimes offer assistance for high bills during droughts or emergencies. Autopay could bypass these relief programs, limiting options. By handling payments manually, you keep the choice to seek help when needed.

Tired of Paying Monopolies Too Much? Here’s How to Slash Your Utility Bills

Childcare Bills

A teacher and five children are seated at a round table, playing with colorful building blocks in a classroom setting.

Childcare costs can fluctuate based on attendance or additional services, making autopay challenging. Missing these adjustments can lead to overpaying or under-budgeting. Paying manually ensures accurate billing, helping you avoid payment surprises.

Errors in childcare billing aren’t uncommon, and autopay can bypass discrepancies. Manually checking each invoice lets you confirm charges, giving you a clear picture of your expenses. This approach prevents potential disputes and keeps childcare costs predictable.

🙋‍♀️If you like what you are reading, then click like and subscribe to my newsletter. We share tips to waste less time and money.

Loan Payments

A man sitting at a desk in a cafe is looking at his smartphone while holding a credit card, with a laptop open in front of him.

Loans, especially personal or small business loans, often have flexible payment options. Autopay may prevent you from adjusting payments if finances shift. Personally managing loan payments gives you the freedom to pay extra or make partial payments.

Some loans allow for early payoff without penalties, but autopay can limit this flexibility. By paying directly, you can choose when to pay more or reduce principal. This approach can save interest over time and lets you adjust based on financial priorities.

Common Types Of Loans Explained Simply

Charitable Donations

People sorting clothes and items in a room with a woman holding a sign that says "Donation.

Regular donations to charities can feel rewarding, but autopay may withdraw when funds are tight. Manually handling donations lets you decide each month, ensuring you’re financially ready to give. This approach protects your budget while supporting causes you value.

Donations can vary during special events or holiday campaigns. With autopay, you might over-commit during these periods. Paying manually keeps you aware of contributions, allowing flexibility in how much you donate each time.

20 Signs You’re Actually Financially Ahead of the Average American

Landscaping or Lawn Care Bills

A home with a lawn and grass in front of it.

Landscaping costs vary with weather, plant maintenance, or special treatments. Autopay may charge for extra services you didn’t authorize. Manually handling payments lets you monitor service frequency, ensuring you only pay for what you need.

Special treatments or one-time services add to costs, and autopay often misses these changes. By reviewing landscaping bills, you ensure charges reflect your agreement. This approach keeps your outdoor maintenance budget in control.

21 Maintenance Tasks Homeowners Should Do Once a Month

Annual Membership Fees

A person hands a pen and document to another person, whose hands are clasped on a table.

Annual membership fees often go unnoticed on autopay, making them easy to forget. This can lead to surprise deductions that disrupt your monthly budget, especially with infrequent payments.

When you pay directly, you’re reminded to assess if the membership is still valuable. Many memberships also have renewal discounts, which autopay may miss entirely. Also, annual fees may increase without prior notice, leaving you to pay more than expected.

Handling these charges allows you to monitor for any rate increases. Reviewing each charge helps you reconsider whether the membership fits your current needs and lifestyle.

25 Sneaky Fees Companies Hide From You (And How You Can Dodge Them)

Parking Passes

Aerial view of a parking lot with a large blue circular arrow pointing left in the center, several parked cars, and designated parking spaces visible.

Parking pass fees can vary with facility changes, making them challenging to monitor on autopay. If your parking pass price changes, autopay may deduct a larger amount without warning. Handling these fees manually ensures you’re always paying the correct rate.

In some cases, monthly parking passes are refundable for unused time, but autopay prevents you from catching these options. Manually paying these fees gives you control over timing and flexibility. This lets you avoid unnecessary charges while adapting payments to fit your schedule.

25 Simple Tax Deductions You Might Be Missing. No Itemizing Needed.

Online Newsletters

A woman with glasses sits on a couch, holding a mug, and uses a laptop. She is covered with a yellow blanket, and there is a lamp and a chair in the background.

Online newsletters often offer introductory rates, which may increase substantially after the first few months. Autopay can charge these higher rates without warning, straining your budget unexpectedly.

Newsletter subscriptions sometimes add fees for premium articles or ad-free options, which autopay may miss. Reviewing each payment keeps you informed of these added charges, preventing surprise deductions.

🙋‍♀️If you like what you are reading, then click like and subscribe to my newsletter. We share tips to waste less time and money.

Storage Unit Fees

A storage unit with its door open, revealing several stacked cardboard boxes and furniture inside. — Image Credit: iStock

Storage unit fees can rise over time due to facility improvements or regional demand. Autopay deducts these increased fees without alerting you, leaving you to pay more than expected. Paying manually helps you monitor for rate hikes and make adjustments.

Extra storage fees for services like access hours or insurance may also be added without notice. Autopay can miss these changes, impacting your budget without warning. When you handle each bill manually, you gain clarity on each charge and can prevent surprises.

Maximize Your Space: Decluttering Strategies for a Happy Home

Security System Monitoring

White 2 Cctv Camera Mounted on Black Post Under Clear Blue Sky

Home security monitoring often includes extra fees for features like live video or additional sensors. Autopay may overlook these fees, causing unexpected charges on your bill. Paying personally ensures you only pay for services you actively use and need.

Security companies frequently adjust rates for their services, and autopay can miss these updates. When you pay directly, you’re reminded to verify each fee and check for any added services.

The 23 Areas of Your House That Are Most Likely to Fail Inspection

Website Hosting Fee

A man and woman sit at a desk, looking at a computer screen and conversing in a modern office space.

Website hosting fees are crucial for business owners and creators but can carry unexpected costs. Hosting services often increase rates after the initial term, which autopay may deduct unnoticed.

Hosting companies also add fees for extra features or bandwidth, which autopay may charge automatically. Paying manually keeps you aware of each service and prevents overpaying for unused options.

Boomers Want to Sell Their Businesses And Retire, But No One’s Qualified. 20 Reasons Why

Digital Storage Subscriptions

A person wearing headphones and glasses is sitting on a bed, writing in a notebook while looking at a laptop. They are surrounded by pillows.

Digital storage services for photos, documents, or software often add new features that increase fees. Autopay may deduct these higher costs without your knowledge, impacting your budget. Manually managing these subscriptions helps you monitor for price changes. This awareness allows you to evaluate if you truly need the additional storage.

Additional fees for larger storage options or backups are common, which autopay may miss. When you pay manually, you can review each option and avoid overpaying for unused space. Managing this expense keeps your storage needs efficient and affordable.

Techs Dirty Secret: 22 Ways Technology Is Quietly Making People’s Lives Worse

Game or Media Passes

A football coach wearing a cap shouts instructions to his players during a game. The players, in navy jerseys and helmets, are gathered around him.

Game and media passes often have promotional rates that increase after the first few months. Autopay may deduct these new rates without notifying you, leading to inflated costs. By paying directly, you’re aware of price changes and can adjust or cancel as needed. This control lets you decide if the pass remains valuable.

Gaming and media companies sometimes offer discounts to retain subscribers, which are missed with autopay. Managing payments allows you to negotiate or seek out savings. This approach lets you enjoy entertainment without overextending your budget.

Raising Kids Doesn’t Have to Be Expensive: 22 Ways to Save Money

Why Staying In Control of Your Payments Matters

A woman in a green blazer smiles while holding stacks of US dollar bills in both hands in an office setting.

The simplicity of autopay may seem like a dream come true for staying on top of bills. But when it comes to certain expenses, taking an active role in paying can give you better control over your budget and prevent unexpected surprises.

By assessing which bills you’re paying automatically, you can avoid overpayments, spot any billing errors quickly, and seize savings opportunities that may otherwise go unnoticed.

Ultimately, choosing when to proactively pay bills rather than using autopay can strengthen your financial footing and offer more flexibility. Start by evaluating each bill to decide which option best aligns with your current financial goals.

Be it catching a small error or holding onto a little more of your hard-earned cash, the benefits of managing these bills hands-on could add up more than you expect.

🙋‍♀️If you like what you just read, then subscribe to my newsletter and follow us on YouTube.👈

AI was used for light editing, formatting, and readability. But a human (me!) wrote and edited this.

22 Bills You Should Actually Avoid Putting on Autopay