S'mores Eyeballs Halloween Easy Dessert Recipe with 3 Ingredients - Marshmallows Chocolate — Halloween Smores

Our annual Halloween block party is approaching and I was trying to think of an easy potluck Halloween treat.

I came up with an idea for Halloween Smores that I decided to try today. It has been rainy all day, and something about the rain makes us want to bake.

Well, I wouldn’t really call this baking… or maybe I’d call it a baking shortcut.

Who loves s’mores? Just about everyone, right? These Smores Halloween eyeballs are made out of just Nilla Wafers, marshmallows, and chocolate chips.

I started with a very small batch because I wasn’t sure how they would turn out. Between my husband, boys, and I, they were gone in an instant.

Then, I made another batch, since the first was so successful. I placed them on a plate, took a few pictures, then put the plate on the counter.

I invited the kids to come downstairs and have a few s’mores eyeballs. Before I could finish the invitation, the s’mores were gone!

After reading this recipe, be sure to check out 13 Quick, Easy Halloween Treats Recipes.

Table of Contents

Halloween Smores Eyeballs – Easy Halloween Treat

Halloween Dessert Recipe: S'mores Eyeballs Easy 3 Ingredients (Chocolate, Marshmallows, Wafers)

Don’t Miss These Ideas

Ingredients To Make Halloween Smores

Nilla Wafers (mini size)
small marshmallows
chocolate chips (any variety; we prefer milk chocolate)

Ghirardelli Milk Chocolate Baking Chips 11.5 oz. (Pack of 2)

$18.59

Buy Now

01/16/2025 06:33 am GMT

Preparing the Smores Eyeballs Halloween Dessert Recipe

S'mores Eyeballs Halloween Potluck Dessert Recipe on Baking Sheet

Directions for Smores Eyeballs

Preheat the oven to 300 degrees.
Then, line a baking sheet with foil or parchment paper.
Lay out the Nilla Wafters (however many you want) with about a half-inch or so between them. I prefer to place the wafers with the curved side up so they look more like rounded eyes.
Next, on top of each wafer place a small marshmallow.
Bake for about 5 minutes.
Then, remove the baking sheet from the oven and carefully press one chocolate chip on each marshmallow wafer. Press down to slightly smoosh the marshmallow and get the chocolate chip to stick.
Return to the oven for about 1 minute.
Next, let cool until the marshmallows and chocolate chips have hardened. This takes only a few minutes.
Finally, eat if you dare!

S'mores Eyeballs Halloween Treat Dessert Recipe

For More Great Ideas, be sure to subscribe to our newsletter!

S’more Eyeball Halloween Treat

Fun and Easy Halloween Treat

Print Recipe Pin Recipe

Prep Time 10

Cook Time 5

cooling 5

Total Time 20

Course Appetizer, Dessert

Cuisine American

Servings 12

Equipment

1 Cookie Sheet
1 Parchment Paper or Aluminum Foil
1 Cooling Rack

Ingredients

Mini Vanilla Wafers or Round Graham Cracker Cookies
Mini Marshmallows
Chocolate Chips Milk Chocolate Melt best

Instructions

Preheat Oven to 300°
Line baking sheet with parchment paper or aluminum foil
Arrange mini Vanilla Wafer on baking sheet- about 1/2 inch apart. Curve side up will result in the best looking "eyeballs"
Top each wafer with a mini marshmallow
Bake for 5 minutes
Carefully remove baking sheet from oven and press 1 chocolate chip into each marshmallow wafer. Press down slightly to smoosh the marshmallow and get the chocolate chip to stick.
Return to the oven for another minute
Remove baking sheet and let the cookies cool until the marshmallows and chocolate chips have harden. This will only take a few minutes.
Eat, if you dare

Keyword cookies, dessert, easy

Other suggestions: If you truly want the s’mores taste you can use graham crackers. Either cut out your own circles or find some graham crackers already cut in circles.

Our Favorite

Earth Breeze

You’ve eaten dehydrated fruit, and it’s still real fruit. Earth Breeze Laundry Sheets are along the same lines. They’re actual laundry detergent but made in eco-friendly sheets. They’re just dehydrated laundry sheets that come in cardboard envelopes.